Which is better Half Life 2 or Gears of War 2?

me and my friend here sit next to each other in this class here and we have been disputing about this for weeks…. we just need alot of opinions and reasons and whatnot. If you've played both games, post an answer.
Please only post answers relevant to the question. For example, here's what you shouldn't say: "gta san andreas", "neither", space invaders".
Also, only post if you've played both games.

Well if you want just plan ratings,
according to gamerankings.com on the XBOX:
Gears of War 2 received a 93.18% based on 75 reviews while
Half Life 2 (The Orange Box) received a 96.09% based on 56 reviews

Both are good in there own way.

Tags: ,

16 Responses to “Which is better Half Life 2 or Gears of War 2?”

  1. Slim Shady says:

    gta san andreasReferences :

  2. Jake G says:

    Neither.References :

  3. King J says:

    Half-Life 2 is legendary. Gears 2 isn't.

    Edit: Don't thumbs down us just because we voice our opinion. You asked for it!References :

  4. vanhalen925 says:

    Half Life 2 Better story better gameplayReferences :

  5. Sarah says:

    World of Warcraft of Call of Duty World at WarReferences :

  6. A FAT MAN YOU MET AT THE MALL says:

    Half Life 2 it rocks it even comes with counter strike if you bought itReferences :

  7. D says:

    Space invadersReferences :

  8. Jake says:

    Gears of War 2References :

  9. Tony says:

    ive only played gears 2 and its not that funReferences :

  10. TomBud10 says:

    Half Life 2 is far and away the better game. GOW wont even be talked about in 2 years time, but the Half Life games are already classics. Console fanboys just can't understand this.References :

  11. xoxCathyxox says:

    GEARS OF WAR 2 is wayy better 🙂 I don't play any of them but my friend plays them all the time and when i watch i know that Gears of War 2 is better, but it's kinda scary lolReferences :

  12. ROCK says:

    HL2. Although Steam is weak.References :

  13. Sergio says:

    half life is more of a team effort o winning
    as in gears 2 its just pretty much killing as many people as you can
    so it really depends on what you like doingReferences :

  14. O K says:

    HL2, i own it, and it's amazing. It's available on more systems, and has a very interactive environment. It's also longer and has 2 expansion packs. So i have to go with HL2, but Gears of war 2 is a great and fun game, i often find myself going to friends houses to play it with them.References :

  15. Winter P says:

    gears of war with out a doubtReferences :

  16. Dainty C says:

    Well if you want just plan ratings,
    according to gamerankings.com on the XBOX:
    Gears of War 2 received a 93.18% based on 75 reviews while
    Half Life 2 (The Orange Box) received a 96.09% based on 56 reviews

    Both are good in there own way.References : http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/index.html

Leave a Reply